Download Against Prediction: Profiling, Policing, and Punishing in an by Bernard E. Harcourt PDF

By Bernard E. Harcourt

From regimen defense tests at airports to using danger evaluation in sentencing, actuarial tools are getting used greater than ever to figure out whom cops objective and punish. And aside from racial profiling on our highways and streets, most folks want those equipment simply because they suspect they’re a less costly technique to struggle crime.In opposed to Prediction, Bernard E. Harcourt demanding situations this starting to be reliance on actuarial equipment. those prediction instruments, he demonstrates, might in reality bring up the final volume of crime in society, counting on the relative responsiveness of the profiled populations to heightened safeguard. they might additionally irritate the problems that minorities have already got acquiring paintings, schooling, and a greater caliber of life—thus perpetuating the trend of felony habit. eventually, Harcourt indicates how the perceived good fortune of actuarial equipment has all started to distort our very notion of simply punishment and to imprecise exchange visions of social order. instead of the actuarial, he proposes as an alternative a flip to randomization in punishment and policing. The presumption, Harcourt concludes, could be opposed to prediction. (20060828)

Show description

Read or Download Against Prediction: Profiling, Policing, and Punishing in an Actuarial Age PDF

Similar criminology books

Hidden Stories of the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry: Personal Reflections

Adolescents who come into touch with cops at the streets this present day have little suggestion of the importance of the stabbing to dying of Stephen Lawrence in a racist assault in 1993. simply their mom and dad or grandparents take note the day-by-day exposures of police incompetence and oblique racism which have been given excessive profile within the media for 6 months.

Private Prisons: Cons and Pros

American prisons and jails are overflowing with inmates. to alleviate the strain, courts have imposed fines on overcrowded amenities and fiscally strapped governments were compelled to free up a variety of prisoners in advance. during this examine, famous criminologist Charles Logan makes the case for advertisement operation of prisons and jails instead to the government's monopoly.

Developing and Maintaining Police-Researcher Partnerships to Facilitate Research Use: A Comparative Analysis

This short discusses tips on how to improve and retain police – researcher partnerships. First, the authors offer details that might be valuable to police managers and researchers who're attracted to developing and keeping partnerships to behavior learn, interact to enhance policing and support others comprehend the linkages among the 2 teams.

Incapacitation: Penal Confinement and the Restraint of Crime

The only, definite method that imprisonment prevents crime is by way of restraining offenders from committing crimes whereas they're locked up. known as "incapacitation" by way of specialists in criminology, this impact has develop into the dominant justification for imprisonment within the usa, the place good over one million people are at the moment in jails and prisons and public figures who are looking to seem difficult on crime periodically urge that we throw away the major.

Additional resources for Against Prediction: Profiling, Policing, and Punishing in an Actuarial Age

Example text

Again, in the case of stranger rape, the benefits of crime reduction, if any, may outweigh the ratchet effect on men since the offense itself involves such serious physical injury. The force of the argument will also depend on the specific group trait that is being profiled. To many, the use of race or class may be problematic, though other profiles, such as marijuana-leaf bumper stickers or tattoos, may be less troubling. While the critiques developed in these pages apply with different force in different contexts, they raise questions and develop methods of analysis that apply to the use of all actuarial measures in the criminal law.

To most people, criminal profiling on a nonspurious trait simply increases the detection of crime and renders police searches more successful, which inevitably reduces crime rates. Although racial profiling may be suspect because of the sensitive issues surrounding race, other forms of criminal profiling—profiling the rich for tax audits, for instance—do not raise similar concerns. There, the calculus is self-evident: the detection of crime will increase, the efficiency of law enforcement will improve, and, through the traditional mechanisms of deterrence and incapacitation, crime rates will decrease.

So, for instance, in this book I expressly invoke a central moral intuition of the criminal law, namely, the idea that similarly situated offenders should be treated alike regardless of race, gender, or class. I privilege this principle of just punishment at the expense of selective incapacitation and also rehabilitation (both of which naturally derive from predictions of future criminality and dangerousness). I locate this principle within the structure of the cost-benefit equation, and argue that it often, though not always, favors resisting the actuarial.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.27 of 5 – based on 21 votes